How to Know If a Therapist Is the Right Fit for You
How to Know If a Therapist Is the Right Fit for You
In a single day, five people in my life brought up the same issue: struggling to find the right therapist. One said she knew she needed support but didn’t know how to find someone who could really meet her needs. Another said she wished she had a therapist who could help her navigate her mood shifts more effectively. And three others — all in therapy already — told me they were considering leaving their current therapists.
When I asked why, their answers were strikingly similar. One felt like his therapist didn’t really listen, often responding with off-target comments or pre-prepared resources that didn’t match what he was sharing. Another said her therapist did most of the talking in sessions, leaving little space for her to bring up what mattered most to her. All three said it felt like each session started from scratch — like their previous work and conversations weren’t carried forward. There was no sense of continuity, no thread of real connection. Two wanted more structure in the sessions, one wanted less.
These conversations reminded me just how important it is to find a therapist who feels like the right fit. It’s not just about qualifications or techniques — though those matter — it’s about whether the relationship feels safe, responsive, and attuned to you. Research consistently shows that the therapeutic alliance (the quality of the relationship between therapist and client) is one of the strongest predictors of positive outcomes in therapy (Norcross & Wampold, 2011).
In this article, we’ll explore what the “right fit” actually means, how to recognize it, and what to do if it feels like something’s missing. Because therapy should be a place where you feel supported, not silenced. Seen, not overlooked. And connected, not alone.
1. Why the Right Fit Matters (therapeutic alliance and outcomes)
Therapy is often thought of as a process of techniques — cognitive reframing, mindfulness skills, exploring the past — but at its core, it’s a relationship. And like any relationship, the quality of that connection matters. A lot.
The right fit in therapy is more than just liking your therapist. It’s feeling safe enough to open up. And that when you do open up, you don’t feel judged or dismissed. It’s being able to trust that your therapist understands you, or is at least committed to trying. When that kind of rapport exists, therapy becomes much more effective. You’re more likely to stay engaged, be honest, and do the deeper work that healing often requires of you.
How connected and understood you feel can matter just as much, if not more, than the “type” of therapy being offered.
On the other hand, when the fit isn’t right, even the best tools can fall flat. You might find yourself holding back, censoring yourself, or feeling like you’re not fully seen. And that can make it hard to make real progress.
This doesn’t mean that every session needs to feel comfortable or easy, because growth can be challenging. Or that every session should be moving mountains, because therapy can have lulls and great progression alike. But you should feel like your therapist is attuned to you. Like you’re building something together, not just going through the motions.
2. What “Fit” Can Look Like — and What It’s Not
When people think about finding the “right fit” with a therapist, it can sound vague — almost like dating advice. “You’ll just know.” But in reality, the experience of fit in therapy can be subtle, layered, and very personal. And often, it’s misunderstood.
Most people assume that a good fit means the therapist is nice, makes them feel comfortable, and is easy to talk to. And while these things are helpful, they’re not the full picture. In fact, therapy that only feels comfortable might not be getting into the deeper material that needs attention.
A true therapeutic fit isn’t about constant ease — it’s about emotional safety. Safety to say what’s really on your mind. Safety to not have it all figured out. Safety to be honest, even about hard things. And safety to feel some discomfort as part of your growth. That’s the difference. When the relationship is built on safety and mutual respect, it can hold both comfort and challenge at the same time.
A good fit might also feel like:
Your therapist “gets” you or is actively working to understand your experience
You feel seen and responded to in a way that feels thoughtful, not automated
You leave sessions feeling slightly more grounded, clear, or emotionally processed — even if it wasn’t easy
The things that matter to you are acknowledged, followed up on, and remembered
The space feels collaborative — like something you’re building together
By contrast, a mismatch in fit often shows up as:
Feeling like your therapist doesn’t remember or track what you’ve shared
Sessions feeling repetitive, disconnected, or overly generic
A sense that your therapist is talking at you, rather than with you
Hesitation to bring up the real issue, or feeling like you’re performing instead of being honest
A therapist bringing up their own issues into your session
A lingering sense that “something’s missing,” even if you can’t quite name it
And here’s another important piece: fit is not the same as similarity. Your therapist doesn’t need to look like you, think like you, or have had the same experiences. What matters more is whether they’re culturally responsive, open to feedback, and able to adapt their approach to support you, not just deliver a prepackaged formula. These are strong predictors of a better therapeutic alliances and outcomes (Hook et al., 2103). When that responsiveness is missing, the therapeutic relationship can start to feel hollow or mechanical, even if everything looks “fine” on the surface.
It’s also okay if the connection takes a few sessions to develop. Some people feel a spark right away. Others need time to settle in and build trust. But if, after several sessions, you find yourself withholding, dreading or wanting to cancel appointments, or leaving feeling more confused than supported… that may be worth paying attention to.
The goal isn’t perfection or constant progress, but is mutual alignment. You should feel like your therapist is really with you, not just there. That they’re attuned to your pace, your needs, and your process — and that the work you’re doing together feels connected over time.
3. Questions to Ask Yourself After a First Session
The first session with a new therapist can feel like a lot: nerves, logistics, storytelling, and a dozen subtle impressions you may not even realize you’re picking up. That’s why it helps to pause afterward and reflect — not just on what was said, but on how you felt.
Here are some helpful questions to consider after that first session:
Did I feel emotionally safe and respected? Not necessarily comfortable the whole time — but did I feel like I could be honest without being judged?
Did my therapist seem present and engaged? Were they listening closely, asking thoughtful questions, or just moving through a checklist?
Was I able to speak freely, or did I just feel like I had to edit or perform? Sometimes nervousness can create this, but if it felt more like self-censorship than a natural first-session feeling, that matters. Keep in mind that it can take a couple of sessions before feeling comfortable with a new therapist.
Did I feel seen or understood - even just a little? It’s ok if your therapist didn’t “get” you fully yet. But did they seem like someone who’s trying to understand?
Was there a sense of structure or intentionality? Did the session have a flow, or did it feel scattered or mechanical?
Could I see myself opening up to this person over time? You don’t have to feel ready to pour your heart out. But does this feel like someone you might be able to trust?
Trust can take time to build. But if you left the session feeling confused, uncomfortable, or like your therapist missed major things you shared, those may be signs to keep an eye on.
And if something felt off, it’s ok to explore that. Remember, therapy is your space to bring up and address anything you want with your therapist. You can bring it up in your next session, reflect more on your own, or even decide to keep looking. You deserve to work with someone who feels attuned to you and your process.
Something to keep in mind is that just as not every therapist is the right fit for every client, not every client is the right fit for every therapist. Sometimes a client has specific needs that a particular therapist may not have training or experience in, while another therapist might specialize in exactly that area. Other times, it simply comes down to personality. Despite all the openness and unconditional positive regard a clinician might bring to the table, not every dynamic will click. Therapists are people too, after all.
This is one of the reasons the therapeutic relationship is often described as a collaborative process, rather than something the therapist alone is responsible for. Both people co-create the environment. You bring your history, your needs, and your emotional truth. The therapist brings their training, presence, and capacity to attune and respond. The space that’s formed between you — when it works — is where healing can happen.
That’s why it’s worth checking in with yourself early on. Not to decide immediately if it’s a perfect match, but to reflect on whether the dynamic feels like it has the potential to be safe, collaborative, and growth-supportive. If it doesn’t feel that way, it’s not a personal failure. It might simply be a mismatch worth exploring or shifting.
4. Red Flags and Green Flags
Red Flags
Red flags are signs that something in the therapeutic relationship might be misaligned or potentially harmful. One of the clearest red flags is feeling invalidated or judged. If a therapist regularly dismisses your emotions, interrupts your experiences, or offers advice before fully listening, it can create an unsafe dynamic (Kern, 2014). A therapist should help you explore your own truth, not impose theirs.
Another red flag is a lack of cultural humility or sensitivity. Research shows that when therapists fail to acknowledge or explore issues of identity — such as race, gender, sexuality, or religion — it can rupture the therapeutic alliance and hinder progress (Hook et al., 2016). For example, if you bring up a racialized experience and your therapist redirects the conversation or minimizes its impact, it may signal a lack of cultural competence.
Other red flags include:
Frequent rescheduling or lack of reliability, which can undermine trust and consistency (Ackerman & Hilsenroth, 2001).
Over-disclosure, where the therapist talks excessively about their own life, shifting focus away from you (Zur, 2017).
Failure to remember key details from prior sessions, which can make you feel like just another name on a caseload rather than a person with a unique story.
Pushing past your boundaries, such as pressing for information or progress too quickly, can feel invasive and counterproductive.
If you’re noticing any of these consistently, and especially if you’ve tried to bring them up and haven’t felt heard, it may be time to reassess whether this therapist is the right match.
Green Flags
On the other hand, green flags are signs that your therapist is creating a safe, responsive, and attuned space for growth. One major green flag is feeling heard and respected, even when you’re struggling to articulate your experience. Research hilights that when clients perceive their therapist as empathic and accepting, treatment outcomes improve significantly (Elliott et al., 2011).
Other important green flags include:
A sense of collaboration - the therapist invites your input, helps set goals with you, and makes adjustments based on your feedback.
Consistency and reliability, which builds trust over time and models a secure relationship (Norcross & Wampold, 2011).
Attunement, where your therapist seems genuinely present, tracks your emotional tone, and reflects your experience accurately.
Willingness to acknowledge mistakes or misunderstandings. A therapist who can own their missteps without defensiveness models healthy repair and reinforces your value in the relationship (Safran & Muran, 2000).
Importantly, the right therapist won’t always feel comfortable — but they will feel trustworthy. When therapy feels collaborative, when our voice is honored, and when you feel like the relationship itself is helping you grow, those are powerful green flags that you’re in the right place.
5. What to Do If It Doesn’t Feel Right
Sometimes, despite your best efforts, therapy just doesn’t feel right. Maybe the connection isn’t there. Maybe you don’t feel understood. Or maybe something just feels off, and you can’t quite name it. Whatever the reason, it’s ok to listen to that inner signal as it can be worth exploring.
First, give it a chance. The beginning of therapy can feel awkward, especially if you’re new to opening up or uncertain about what to expect. But like any relationship, it takes time to build. It’s normal to need a few sessions to settle in, get a feel for the therapist’s approach, and see if something begins to click.
Still, if something continues to feel “off”, ask yourself: Do I feel emotionally safe in this place? Do I feel heard, seen, and respected? Do I feel like I can be myself here, even if I’m struggling? If the answer is consistently no, that’s important to acknowledge. Sometimes, what feels “off” is actually your body and intuition picking up on something your mind hasn’t fully processed yet.
If you’re unsure, consider bringing it up in session. This might feel intimidating, but it can be surprisingly empowering, and illuminating as well. Saying something like, “I’m not sure this is feeling like the right fit, and I’d like to talk about it”, can open the door to realignment, deeper understanding, or a clearer sense of your needs. A therapist who responds with openness and curiosity rather than defensiveness is showing a green flag: the capacity to repair, attune, and center your needs.
If the conversation confirms that this isn’t the right fit, it’s ok to move on. Seeking a better match is part of taking your mental health seriously. You deserve a space that feels emotionally safe and growth-oriented. Research supports that client preference and perceived alliance are major factors in treatment effectiveness (Swift et al., 2011), so honoring your needs is not only valid but it’s therapeutic in itself.
And if you do decide to look for someone new, try not to let discouragement stop you. Reflect on what worked and what did’t. This experience gave you more clarity than you had before. You now have a better sense of what you need in a therapist and that insight will help guide you to your next practitioner.
Therapy is about you. Your time, your emotional safety, and your healing matter. If something doesn’t feel right, you’re allowed to listen to that. It’s not quitting, it’s choosing yourself.
Final Thoughts
Finding the right therapist is a process. It’s not always easy, and it may take a few tries before something truly clicks. This is normal. Therapy is a relationship, not a transaction. You’re allowed to expect more than surface-level support. Feeling seen, heard, and emotionally safe matters and is worth holding out for.
If your past experiences with therapy haven’t felt right, please don’t give up! It’s okay to walk away from a therapist who wasn’t the right match and to continue looking for someone who is. Trust yourself. You don’t need to be an expert in psychology to know when something isn’t working for you. Your discomfort is valid and your intuition is valuable.
Give yourself credit for even asking these questions and reflecting on your experience. Wanting a good therapeutic fit is not a sign of being picky or high-maintenance. It’s a sign that you are honoring yourself and taking your mental health seriously. A good therapist won’t silence that voice — they’ll support it. They’ll help you feel like a collaborator in your healing, not a passive recipient of advice.
Keep going. You’re allowed to outgrow support that no longer serves you. You’re allowed to expect more than just being “fine”. You’re allowed to take up space in your own healing journey. If you’re not sure where to begin, consider reading therapist bios, checking their areas of focus, and noticing how you feel during a consultation. The right therapist is out there, and you’re absolutely worth the search.
ReferencesAckerman, S. J., & Hilsenroth, M. J. (2001). A review of therapist characteristics and techniques positively impacting the therapeutic alliance. Clinical Psychology Review, 21(1), 1–33.Elliott, R., Bohart, A. C., Watson, J. C., & Greenberg, L. S. (2011). Empathy. Psychotherapy, 48(1), 43–49.Flückiger, C., Del Re, A. C., Wampold, B. E., & Horvath, A. O. (2018). The alliance in adult psychotherapy: A meta-analytic synthesis. Psychotherapy, 55(4), 316–340.Hook, J. N., Davis, D. E., Owen, J., Worthington, E. L., & Utsey, S. O. (2013). Cultural humility: Measuring openness to culturally diverse clients. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 60(3), 353–366.Kern, R. M. (2014). Validation in psychotherapy: The art of helping clients feel understood. Journal of Individual Psychology, 70(3), 205–216.Norcross, J. C., & Lambert, M. J. (2018). Psychotherapy relationships that work III. Psychotherapy, 55(4), 303–315.Norcross, J. C., & Wampold, B. E. (2011). Evidence-based therapy relationships: Research conclusions and clinical practices. Psychotherapy, 48(1), 98–102.Safran, J. D., & Muran, J. C. (2000). Negotiating the therapeutic alliance: A relational treatment guide. Guilford Press.Swift, J. K., Callahan, J. L., Ivanovic, M., & Kominiak, N. (2011). Further examination of the psychotherapy preference effect: A meta‐regression analysis. Psychotherapy Research, 23(3), 301–311. Zur, O. (2017). Boundaries in psychotherapy: Ethical and clinical explorations. Psychotherapy Bulletin, 52(3), 8–13.